I’m not going to give predictions here. I did not see as many of the contenders as I would have liked and I’m more interested in commenting on the snubs and surprises.
SURPRISES
1. Jonah Hill
I watched Moneyball during my flight to Rome and I could not hear very well, but I found it interesting that the Academy chose to recognize him. The Academy is starting to recognize young Hollywood and I like it!
2. Melissa McCarthy
Performance of the year. So what if it’s comedy? It is brilliant. I had never thought much of her during her days on Gilmore Girls but this performance put her on the map. If she doesn’t win I’ll cry, or invent an award and give it to her myself.
3. Rooney Mara
I loved the book series and was way too excited for the film. Subsequently, the film was very anticlimactic. However, Rooney Mara exceeded my expectations. I highly doubt she will take home the statue but this can only lead to good things for Ms. Mara and her career.
4. Joseph Gordon-Levitt
50/50 was a terrific and underappreciated film. Joseph Gordon-Levitt has consistently done well in all of his work included and not limited to his performances in 500 Days of Summer and Inception. I would like to ask the Academy to (please) recognize his talent.
SNUBS
1. Shailene Woodley
I liked The Help. However, I did not love it. I did love The Descendants and thought that Ms. Woodley gave a phenomenal performance, especially for someone of her age and experience. Given the surprises in this year’s nominations I was sure that she could snag a spot in the Best Supporting Actress category.
2.
Leonardo Di Caprio
I did not see J. Edgar. I just assumed Mr. DiCaprio would be nominated for it. He is typically thrown into the mix every year, though he has often been overlooked for wonderful work in films like Romeo+Juliet, Revolutionary Road and Inception. In the meantime his equally as talented friend, Kate Winslet, can console him and lament the fact that he has the curse she used to have where one is continually nominated yet never rewarded.
3. Ryan Gosling
This talented actor has only been recognized for Half Nelson (which is a great film). He has been passed up for Lars and the Real Girl, Blue Valentine, Ides of March, and Drive. And he gave even BETTER performances in ALL of these films (save for Drive which I can’t comment on because I have not seen it).
4. Evan Rachel Wood
She was fantastic in Ides of March, which I believe to be the best film of the year. She was recognized for her work in Mildred Pierce by the Globes and Emmys, and her body of work only becomes more varied and interesting as time goes on. The Academy is starting to recognize “Young Hollywood” and she should be at the top of their list.
5. Paul Giamatti/Philip Seymour Hoffman
Both are older gentlemen who are typically recognized and both gave fantastic performances. I doubt they care at this point but all the same, at least one of them should have been nominated.
6. Anna Kendrick/Seth Rogan
I’m not surprised that the two are not nominated. They are young and this film was not appreciated the way it should have been. Nevertheless, they were snubbed.
7.Felcity Jones/Anton Yelchin
Like Crazy was not the greatest film. However, the performance were raw and moving. Let's recognize young Hollywood and newcomers all the time.
This was the best film I saw all year. It was snubbed in terms of acting and directing. Tsk Tsk.
On a Side Note…
I really enjoyed that Jennifer Lawrence read the nominations. The Academy wants to be “cool” and cater to a younger audience. After last year’s failure of Anne Hathaway and James Franco as hosts they decided this was the way to do it. This is preferable.
Also, they probably know that Jennifer Lawrence is the epitome of cool and that The Hunger Games is going to be fantastic. But that’s just me…
I also apologize to Andrea for our entries being so similar, we just held very similar opinions this season.